How to Size Leather Handmade Shoes and How Long Does It Take to Break Them In?

When it comes to buying leather handmade shoes, the fit and comfort are key to making the perfect choice. Unlike mass-produced shoes, handmade leather shoes are crafted with precision and care, making them an investment in quality and style. But how do you ensure the perfect fit? And how long does it take for your new shoes to feel just right? Let’s delve into these essential questions and guide you on how to size your handmade leather shoes and the breaking-in process.


1. How to Size Leather Handmade Shoes

Sizing leather shoes can be a bit different from ready-made footwear, especially when they are handmade. Since the shoe is crafted to your specific size, it’s important to follow these steps:

How to Size Leather Handmade Shoes

Sizing leather shoes can be a bit different from ready-made footwear, especially when they are handmade. Since the shoe is crafted to your specific size, it’s important to follow these steps:

  1. Know Your Exact Size
    The first step is to measure your feet. It’s not just about the length; take into account the width as well. Use a brannock device (a foot measuring tool) to get accurate measurements of both foot length and width.
  2. Check the Brand’s Sizing Chart
    Every handmade leather shoe brand has its own sizing chart, which might differ slightly from other brands. Be sure to check this chart before placing your order. Most brands provide guidelines for US, UK, or EU sizing, but keep in mind that shoe sizes can also vary based on the construction method.
  3. Consider Shoe Type & Design
    The design of the shoe matters. Loafers, Oxfords, and Boots all have different fits. If you’re ordering lace-up shoes like derby shoes or wingtip oxfords, they tend to offer more flexibility for adjusting to foot shape compared to slip-on shoes like loafers or moccasins.
  4. Custom Fit Options
    Many artisans and brands offer custom sizing options, which is a great choice if you have unique foot dimensions (wide feet, high arches, etc.). You may need to send in measurements or have a virtual fitting consultation.
  5. Order Half Sizes if Available
    If you’re in-between sizes, it’s always best to opt for a half size if the brand offers it. Leather shoes can stretch and mold to your feet, but starting with a good fit will make the process easier.

How Much Time Does It Take to Break in Handmade Leather Shoes?

Once you’ve got your perfect pair of leather handmade shoes, the next step is to break them in. This process allows the leather to conform to your feet, making the shoes more comfortable over time. Here’s a breakdown of what to expect:

  1. Initial Comfort
    Leather shoes, especially high-quality full-grain leather, will feel stiffer initially. Expect them to have some tightness around the areas that come into contact with your feet. Handmade shoes tend to have better structure and durability, so the initial discomfort is part of the process.
  2. Breaking-in Period: 1-2 Weeks
    Typically, it will take about 1 to 2 weeks of wearing your leather shoes regularly to break them in. You don’t need to wear them all day right away, but gradually increase the time you wear them to help the leather soften. Avoid wearing them for long hours during the first few days.
  3. Leather Molding to Your Feet
    As you wear the shoes, the natural leather will begin to soften and mold to the shape of your feet. Hand-stitched shoes may take a little longer, as the stitching needs time to settle and allow the leather to stretch.
  4. Using Leather Conditioners
    To aid in the process, you can apply a small amount of leather conditioner or shoe polish to nourish the leather and keep it supple. This will help reduce stiffness and speed up the break-in process.
  5. Signs of a Proper Break-in
    After the break-in period, the shoes should feel much more comfortable, with the leather softening and the shoes adjusting to your feet. There should be no more tightness or discomfort, and the shoes should be more flexible.

Tips to Help Speed Up the Break-In Process:

  • Wear Thick Socks: Initially, wearing thicker socks can help create a buffer and ease the pressure while the shoes are breaking in.
  • Stretching Tools: If certain areas are too tight, you can use a shoe stretcher to gently widen them, especially around the toe box or heel.
  • Leather Softening Products: Some products are designed to soften leather. Apply them sparingly, as too much product can affect the finish.

Conclusion

Sizing and breaking in handmade leather shoes requires patience and attention to detail, but the rewards are well worth it. By taking the time to find the right size, and carefully breaking in your shoes, you’ll enjoy a perfect fit and long-lasting comfort. Remember, quality leather shoes are an investment, and with proper care, they will only get better with time, molding to your feet and providing superior comfort for years to come.

At Leather Edges, we take great pride in handcrafting shoes that not only look stunning but also deliver a custom fit. Enjoy your journey into the world of handmade footwear, where quality and comfort meet timeless style.